LSU Has Plenty of Reasons to Question the First College Football Playoff Rankings

The countdown to the Selection Show begins.

The first of many College Football Playoff shows has begun, with LSU as a possible competitor for a postseason run, with the upcoming month turning these dreams into realities.

While the LSU fan base might initially react to the team's seeding, there's more to the ranking: the committee's internal thoughts on placing these 25 teams based on how the season has gone.

The Ranking Results

With a 6-2 record, ranked at the No. 15 seed in the Top 25 AP Poll, the LSU Tigers sit at the No. 14 seed in the first CFP rankings.

This means that if the Selection Show aired tonight, the Tigers are slated to be outside of the initial playoff picture. As the five power conference champions get automatic entry, the next seven ranked teams are next, with No. 12 or higher as the ideal cutoff.

As the rest of the bracket was released, the committee ranked six conference teams over LSU: Tennessee at No. 13, Ole Miss at No. 10, Texas at No. 7, Kentucky at No. 6, Alabama at No. 5, and Georgia at No. 2.

Two of LSU's losses so far sit in front of the Tigers in the rankings, while three of its next opponents also receive a higher ranking. If LSU wants to squeeze into that ideal spot, it must prove to the committee it's postseason-worthy over these top-ranked teams.

As Tennessee, Alabama, Ole Miss, and Texas all join LSU in the two-loss boat, it raises key questions about how the committee is comparing these teams so far this season.

The Committee Question

As the committee strategically placed these teams in the first rankings from their records, the strength of schedules and marquee wins/losses, there is a common standard within the rankings.

But the question is, are all teams receiving this same standard?

LSU has not only remained in the top 25 all ten weeks of the season, but has also been able to set the tone against opponents that other teams haven't. When the Tigers win, they win big. While the losses come up more narrow, losing two road games by a combined total of nine points.

If the rankings are putting top-ranked teams in for marquee wins, the standard of what translates to a marquee win should be treated fairly towards every team in order to see fair seeding.

LSU has shown this aggression from the first game, with a 51-10 blowout win over Clemson. In SEC play, the team dominated ranked Texas A&M 35-6 and shut out Mississippi State 31-0.

This resum has painted a clear picture for the committee: that they are able to win big over big-name programs, and rarely let a loss define the team.

So when taking these marquee wins into account, the committee can't move the goalpost to shift to strength of schedule, putting another team's gritty win over a team that's proven its dominance in the conference week after week.

Sign up toour free newsletterand follow us onFacebookandXfor the latest news.

Today's best reads

• LSU's First College Football Playoff Ranking Will Show How Much Work Remains
• LSU Cannot Let Its Resurgence Become More False Hope
• Where LSU Landed in the First College Football Playoff Rankings of 2026
• Lane Kiffin Was Hired to Beat Teams Like Alabama
• Where LSU Stands in College Football Playoff Race After Week 8

This article was originally published on www.si.com/college/lsu as LSU Has Plenty of Reasons to Question the First College Football Playoff Rankings.